Re: American Idol chat

Gutter Thu Mar 19, 2009 9:25 am

I am not liking this judges save thing. I think it is cruel the way they are doing it - you have to sing for us again and then we will decide if you are 'save' worthy. It seems like they crush 'em twice in a row and give them some false hope instead of just a clean thanks but it's over.

I agree and Alexis also sang her song from the night before, how is that suppose to help change the judges decision. I liked her...not enough for her to win, but I thought she was good on her other songs.

I didn't get to watch Tuesday night so I only got the lowdown from last night on how they did.

**Lily*Blossom** Thu Mar 19, 2009 10:43 am

I agree that in a way, the judges save thing is super mean.

But one good thing about it is that the contestants think they still have a chance, so they aren't bawling through their entire song if they are asked to sing again!!!!

dolly's momma Thu Mar 19, 2009 11:28 am

Gutter wrote:
I didn't get to watch Tuesday night so I only got the lowdown from last night on how they did.

You can see the performances online. Go to rickey.org. If you click on a contestant's name and song title it takes you to another screen, and if you scroll down there is a video box to play it.

Gutter Thu Mar 19, 2009 12:19 pm

thanks DM!!

Sponsored content